Butter Me Up Organics: Product Review Collection
We're systematically analyzing Butter Me Up Organics products based on real customer reviews. Each analysis examines hundreds of reviews to identify patterns, effectiveness, and common issues.
What You Need to Know About This Brand
The Real Story
Started in 2008 by Jillian Haddad who spent three years perfecting each recipe after being frustrated with overpriced body butters. Now a 17-year-old business with 30,000+ Etsy sales and nationwide retail presence.
Why We Trust Them
- EWG verified - "LOW HAZARD" ratings (third-party safety testing)
- 13+ years online - Website running since 2012
- Retail presence - Stocked in 25+ states including Scottsdale spas
- Founder-made - Jillian still personally crafts products
- Zero waste since 2008 - Glass/tin packaging, plastic-free shipping
Bottom Line: You're buying from someone who's been doing this longer than Instagram has existed. The same formulas that built their reputation are still made by the same person who created them. No venture capital, no mass production, no formula changes when they got popular.
30,000+
Etsy Sales
4.85
Avg Rating
Top 1%
Etsy Shop
Est. 2008
In Business
Completed Product Reviews
| Product | Reviews Analyzed | Rating | Starting Price | Key Finding | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Magnesium Lotion | 552 | 4.91/5 | $30 | Sleep improvement (49% of reviews) | Read Analysis |
Coming Soon
- Natural Deodorant (160 reviews)
- Healing Body Cream (124 reviews)
- Charcoal Toothpaste (1,022 reviews)
- Face Mask/Hydrating Mask (192 reviews)
- Natural Face Moisturizer (56 reviews)
- Eczema Cream (42 reviews)
Our Review Process
We analyze customer reviews from multiple sources to identify patterns that individual shoppers might miss. For Butter Me Up Organics, we're focusing on their most-reviewed hero products.
Each analysis includes:
- Rating distribution breakdown
- Common benefits and complaints
- Usage patterns and tips from customers
- Comparison insights when customers mention alternatives
- Success rates for specific concerns
Visit Butter Me Up Organics
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.